September 4, 2007

Fire station in southwestern Bristol?

BRISTOL – While candidates generally agree that adding more hydrants in the fast-growing southwestern section will help improve fire safety, some are ready to go further.
At least two city councilors, Frank Nicastro and Kevin McCauley, said they favor a new firehouse closer to the area in order to slice response times in a crisis.
Among all the municipal candidates who answered questions from the Press, only Democratic mayoral nominee Ellen Zoppo threw cold water on the idea.
Zoppo, a three-term councilor, said the city has “a good working relationship with Wolcott which was a fire house on the southern side of Cedar Lake and the Terryville station on Fall Mountain.”
Moreover, she said, “I believe response rates to this area from” the central firehouse downtown “is acceptable, and I am not aware of any instance where delayed response has been an issue.”
That runs contrary to what McCauley, a city firefighter, had to say.
He said, as did Zoppo, that a lack of water lines and hydrants doesn’t help. But the Water Department has been extending lines during the last few years and is continuing its efforts to bring municipal water to more of the area.
But McCauley also said that another reason for concern is “the absence of a fire station” close to the neighborhoods in that part of Bristol.
“Past studies have shown a need for coverage based in this region for quicker response times,” he said.
“Simply moving Fire Headquarters to a closer location, while maintaining a downtown presence, would not be enough, especially with more subdivisions being developed,” McCauley said.
A new station for the area “will have a beneficial effect on insurance ratings for the city and homeowners,” he added.
Former Mayor Frank Nicastro, who is seeking a second term as a councilor in the 3rd District, said he has long pushed for a firehouse that could better serve the southwestern area of town with its “massive growth.”
“They should strongly look at putting something up there” on Fall Mountain, Nicastro said.
As it is, he said, it takes as much as seven minutes for a fire truck to reach that section of the city, which is too long.
Nicastro said the firehouses were placed in the right spots decades ago but population shifts need to be taken into account now.
“We could make some moves and shift things around,” Nicastro said.
City Councilor Art Ward, who is challenging Zoppo in the Sept. 11 mayoral primary, said the “the southwestern section of the city needs to have city services of water, sewer and fire safety made available to property owners, as soon as possible, in a timely and affordable manner.”
“The city has recently completed a water pump station to service this area and consideration is being given to the future” location or relocation of a firehouse to provide more coverage there, Ward said.
“While it appears there is a need for a fire station in this portion of the city, we have to proceed carefully,” said Ken Cockayne, a 2nd District Republican council contender. He said the city has to keep the big picture in mind.
Joe Geladino, a 2nd District council hopeful, also said the southwestern part of the city “needs better police and fire protection.”
“We don’t necessarily need a new firehouse, but increasing the infrastructure to include water lines and fire hydrants would certainly bolster the existing fire protection,” he said.
“A long-term plan might include moving the existing fire station from the center of downtown to a location that would better serve this section of town, perhaps to a location on or in the vicinity of Divinity Street,” Geladino said.
Tom Ragaini, a former councilor who is running as an independent for the council in the 2nd District, said a new firehouse may be necessary. He said he would like to see more study.
City Councilor Craig Minor, a Democrat, said he “would hope that the Board of Fire Commissioners is fully aware of this situation and that the commissioners will make a recommendation at the appropriate time.”
“The City Council relies on these boards to provide expert oversight on technical infrastructure issues,” he said.
“At the risk of being overly bureaucratic,” Cockayne said, “I would propose that a study be completed with heavy emphasis the input of our fire personnel. Who in this city knows better the needs of our emergency personnel then the men and women who are doing the job themselves?”
Bob Merrick, a 3rd District GOP council candidate, said he would like to see a forum for residents to ask representatives from the police, fire and emergency medical services questions about public safety and to hear residents’ ideas for change.
Every major mayor and council candidate was given the chance to respond to the question. Some did not answer. Others said they preferred not to comment.


*******
Copyright 2007. All rights reserved.
Contact Steve Collins at scollins@bristolpress.com

20 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is very bothersome to me. All of the candidates EXCEPT ELLEN agree that something needs to be done to better protect this area of town which is undeniably growing at an incredible pace.

It does not make me feel comfortable to have a potential city leader pawn the responsibility of fire protection off on two neighboring towns that do not have the advanced protective services that we have. They are also volunteer services which leads to a delay in response.

I think this is a very irresponsible stance for Ellen to take, especially after all of the years that she served on the fire board. She should know better. What are her priorities?

Anonymous said...

That is Ellen for you - and if those towns are using their fire dept. for a fire where does that leave Bristol? If it were my home and response time was the issue, I would go after Ellen.

Ellen would not be good for Bristol!

Anonymous said...

I am sure if Ellen had a house at that end of town - she would be for a new firehouse! But, typical Ellen, if is doesn't directly relate to her, she is not for it.
How sad that her concern is on who took her signs then the safety of our community. Some piece of leadership Ellen. My vote is NOT for you.

Anonymous said...

That's the strange part. She has a family home on Cedar Lake. She would benefit directly to having a closer firehouse. What I don't understand is why she is against it? Would it take money away from other projects she would like to see happen?

Anonymous said...

Where does the Union President, Bentivengo stand on this issue? He's been a member of the fire department for many many years. I'd be interested to see if he feels that this section of town needs closer protection.

Anonymous said...

Ellen does have a house in that part of town.

Anonymous said...

VOLUNTEER ONLY

Anonymous said...

Agreed, it is odd that she would be opposed to a move like this. One would think that she would at the very least jump on the band wagon to shore up her campaign. Sort of use it like a political hot button.I guess she cant afford to spare the time, too busy trying to plug all the knife holes in the backs of the people she now realizes needs.

Steve Collins said...

To be entirely fair to Ellen, I thought I'd let you see the question I asked and her answer.

My question: "As you know, the southwestern part of the city is growing fast and is perhaps dangerously far from a fire station. What would you do to expand fire coverage there? And what else would you have the city do to improve services in that part of Bristol?"

This is Zoppo's answer:
"Bringing water to the southwest section will be a big safety improvement since hydrants will then be available. We also have a good working relationship with Wolcott which was a fire house on the southern side of Cedar lake and the Terryville station on fall Mountain. I believe response rates to this area from Fire Headquarters is acceptable, and I am not aware of any instance where delayed response has been an issue.
"The Plan of development also calls for acquisition of open space in this area for passive use or for park purposes, since there is not a park in the area now."

As you can see, her answer goes beyond the fire station issue. It just worked out that the fire issue was the one that most candidates latched onto, and it became the story.

Anonymous said...

Thank you Steve for giving us all of the information but I'm still not happy with her answer. She is aware that the growth in this area is quickly turning massive which proper planning ahead would make cause for a new fire house, not just bringing more water up to the area and relying on a working relationship with neighboring towns.

As the growth continues the response time will suffer. More populated neighborhoods to negotiate through.

Considering moving the downtown firehouse to another location with easier access to Rt 69 would be a good start.

Dismissing the idea is a mistake.

Anonymous said...

"She wants a park", "She wants passive recreation", Its wahtn "she wants" not what the people in Bristol NEED. Hey, why not put a dog park up at cedar lake too?

Anonymous said...

A seven minute response time is NEVER acceptable....by any standard! I think, Miss Zoppo, that you clearly exhibit the problem of your predecessors. That is to keep playing the odds and bet the house that nothing serious is going to happen.
We need forward thinkers that can plan for the future and can anticipate for growth in a positve manner. Limiting public safety, such as fire protection, is definitely not progressive and shows that you are indifferent to the needs of the city and the people you may be working for. (* Yes, my political friends, elected officials work for the citizenry!)

Anonymous said...

Good for Ellen. I finally agree with her on something!!

Way to go Ellen! You're starting to interest me.

Thank you for standing for the tax payers. The people up there knew there was no fire station. All of a sudden they want one. Well duh! Wait to re-evaluation and watch your taxes go through the roof as well.

Anonymous said...

You are right, people built up there knowing that there wasn't a firehouse but they were also led to believe that the City was seriously considering one up there for the past five years - since Nicastro's last year as Mayor it has been considered based on the recommendation of the Fire Chief Jon Pose.

Everything about this area leads to reasons why they need an EMS/Firehouse closer. The more people you put in an area, the more likely something will happen that requires emergency services. More vehicles raises the chances for a crash. More people raises the chances for injury. More houses raises the chance for fire.

Growth in that area is not slowing down, it is increasing. Proactive safety solutions should be considered now.

Anonymous said...

So if my taxes pay for fire safety, where is my fire safety? I pay taxes in Bristol for this service and I have to rely on Wolcott & Terryville??? Pull yourself away from the mirror Ellen and realize the growth of this city, & its needs. There are many houses that are older, which means they burn faster and response time can mean the difference between life and death.

Anonymous said...

I wonder how ellen would feel if Daddy's house on Cedar Lake burned to the ground b/c the fire department was not there in five minutes?

As for the blogger who said people built up there too bad, Remember if people didn't build up there your taxes would be much higher than they are now. Let's stop this class warfare and look out for all Bristol residents

Anonymous said...

I agree - it doesn't matter the size of the house, we should all have the fire safety.

Anonymous said...

Clueless Anon: You think your single family houses are making my taxes lower? You're totally ignorant. Single family houses are tax losers.

As far as "Ellen's daddy's" cottage, I'm sure he knew well enough that there are risks involved in owning the property.

I assume you're not familiar with anyone who owns a cottage by a lake (anywhere), but it's rare that there is full time fire people available for those types of situations.

Anonymous said...

This isn't a neighborhood of summer cottages that are only occupied for a couple months out of the year. Cedar Lake is a year round neighborhood and they deserve adequate fire protection. It isn't just Cedar Lake though. It's that entire corner of the City that isn't protected well.

Most of the houses up there are assessed in excess of $400K - which keeps the taxes lower for those of us who own homes that are assessed at only $175K. Expensive homes build up our grand list.

We have great fire protection everywhere else in the City except that section of town. They need more than just water lines.

Anonymous said...

Cottages by the lake??? Shows how long its been since you have been at Cedar Lake.

I guess you still think you can swim at Kory's Beach, huh?