April 16, 2008

Yarde weighs in on city management problems

Businessman Craig Yarde weighed in recently with a couple of interesting comments on another post. I want to make sure everyone sees them, so here they are:

First time to the Bristol Blog.
I wish everyone would use their real names rather than anonymous. I tried to post a comment a few days ago using my name Craig Yarde but it never went through. Maybe because I didn't know my URL, whatever that is. So I'll try anonymous and see if it makes it.
My main reason I like a city manager or COO is because I feel the last four Mayors who I know personally did not manage their twenty one direct reports. One Mayor told me he spent half his week hearing citizens complaints. We all know the ceremonial responsibilities and meetings the Mayor has to perform under the city charter. I would say a Mayor has a sixty hour plus week without ever managing his twenty one direct reports. Having running Yarde Metals for over 30 years, managing my direct reports was the hardest thing I had to do. It's a tough job to review everyone twice a year and have meetings with each one every few weeks to see how he/she is performing the goals and objectives
for each department. I had six associates reporting to me. I can't imagine what would happen if I had twenty one associates reporting to me and not meeting with them at all. Let me give you an example what happens when you don't manage your people. Under Mayor Stortz, it well documented in the Bristol Press about his issues with the BDA department head Jonathan Rosenthal.
There was also concerns about Jonathan's performance with the previous two administrations. Personally, I think he did a good job, but i was the customer not the boss. Well, Mayor Stortz bypassed the BDA and formed another committee to handle the mall project. Jonathan had already did the RFQ for the new mall project. Jonathan who makes about $100,000 per year job was in limbo for these two years as they bypassed him. The mayor asked me to be on this committee which I agreed until I found out he was bypassing the BDA. I respectfully told him I didn't agree with what he was doing and refused to be on the new mall committee. They have budgeted three hundred and fifty thousand dollars
for legal fees to set this committee up along with other expenses. Since the pass four mayors have not at all managed their twenty one direct reports their was nothing in Jonathans personnel file. No reviews, no verbal warnings, no written warnings, nothing at all. So there was no valid argument to dismiss him. Knowing the laws, I would guess it will cost the city anywhere from $500,000 to a million dollars to dismiss Jonathan Rosenthal. The main reason is he was managed so poorly. My question to fellow bloggers is what do you think the mayor should do at this
point to handle this individual. A very difficult situation. Can you see the legal difficulty by not managing you direct reports. There was a recent department head that sued the city for $250,000 dollars for the same reason. All I want is to protect the city and prevent our tax dollars from getting wasted for lack of management. We are talking some very serious money here that gets wasted. Your tax dollars.If know of any other areas were money has been squandered. Please email me at hirecoo@gmail.com Thank you.

And there's this one, too:
I did not include Leone in my remarks and by the way he is a strong supporter of the Charter Revision Committee to create a COO position. I know Artie has recently put some warnings in Jonathan's file but the horse is out of the barn. Because Frank, Couture and Bill has never given any reviews, no verbal and no written warnings and have given very little direction to department heads, the stage is already set. I have heard rumors of antisemitic remarks and one mayor grabbing Jonathan's ass but it's only hearsay at this stage. It will all come out in the wash when Bristol decides to do something with his employment. What we have here is lifetime employment in the city unless we decide to pay him to leave and that will be big bucks. I didn't say anything about public impute to the mall or nothing being accomplished. What I'm saying is we are not managing the people side of the city business which will get the city in big law suits in the future unless we let everyone have lifetime employment. Is that what we want?
Craig Yarde

*******
Copyright 2008. All rights reserved.
Contact Steve Collins at scollins@bristolpress.com

56 comments:

Steve Collins said...

For those wondering about the Rosenthal comments, I can only say... I'm not sure. My impression from talking with city officials is that he's still under fire despite getting reappointed in January.

Anonymous said...

Thanks, Craig! This is better than TV!

Anonymous said...

This is what happens when the mayor's seat is a popularity contest and not a competency contest. I give Craig Yarde a lot of credit for saying what a lot of people are thinking. But, I still think if we elect the right people, and hadn't had a whole bunch of different mayors over the past 5 years, things would be a little better. So some of us fickle voters are to blame as well.

Anonymous said...

What mayor has hands that big?

Anonymous said...

If it all really does come out in the wash as Craig says, that's going to be one mighty big load of laundry.

Anonymous said...

WE don't need a manager, we just need a competent mayor.

Anonymous said...

Craig, What Bristol wanted and needed was for Yarde Metals and you to be a little more patient and wait for the Bugryn family to make their decision instead of leaving because they didn't throw the family out fast enough for you.Now you want to run Bristol without your business.

Anonymous said...

Getting interesting.
Sounds like Craig has gotten his hands on personal files.

Has he?

Sounds like Craig has spent time interviewing mayors.

Has he?

Sounds like Craig has gone to a lot of city meetings?

Has he

Does he know how many repremands have been given out?
Unless he had access to personnel files, he wouldn't know.

And the way I see itm there is a HUGE difference between a Town Manger and COO.

Granted, things could be better, but here we have a person who chose not to be involved, according to his own admission, but feels comfortable chirping from the outside.

Craig, we all like you, you do do good things, but roll up your sleeves, get involved.

You might learn something.

Anonymous said...

All of a sudden this guy knows all about how the city is manged.
I don't recall seeing him at city meetings.


I don't recall hearing him speak out when the rosenthal issue was on the table.

Mr. Yarde, do some homework.

Anonymous said...

Gee, you could have been part of the solution and chose not to.

Why not?

Anonymous said...

April 16, 2008 10:58 PM:

So you're sayiong we'd be better with 8 years of Couture?

Anonymous said...

Sounds to me like Craig is applying for the job.

Anonymous said...

Craig,

Thanks for answering my questions and the questions of others. From what you have written it seems that you are correct in your opinion.

I would hope if this positon is created however, there is a reconfiguration of the mayor's compansation package (reduction).

Anonymous said...

It sounds like Rosenthal's got a big lawsuit ready to roll if the city tries to fire him. Thanks for the professional way you handled the man, Mayor Stortz. You screwed it up.

Anonymous said...

I am not clear as to how Stortz screwed up. I would believe that he talked to city attorneys first.

At least he did not do what was done before with at least one other department head, fire him, unannounced, at a city council meeting. That cost us big bucks, didn't it.

Try to get get rid of him now AFTER he was reppointed will create even bigger problems.

Anonymous said...

Craig,

Great job! Perhaps if Frank didn't drag his feet Yarde Metal would still be in town.

Keep up the good work! Craig Yarde "Moving Bristol Forward"!

Ward will vote no on this issue! The unions have him in there pocket and will never let him vote for the COO!

Ward = Union!!

Anonymous said...

Well my guess is that is was NOT Stortz who grabbed his butt-end. My guess it was the guy who was discharged from the police force.

Anonymous said...

When's the "anti-naysayer" going to chime in and insult us all as well?

Anonymous said...

Anti-semitic remarks? Not hard to guess who might have made them!

Anonymous said...

ANYONE can guess, but does anyone know?

Gerontius said...

He probably called the Personnel Department (584-6175) and asked to see Rosenthal's file, and they probably told him don't bother because it's empty. It's a public document so they would have to show it to him.

Anonymous said...

On the next episode of "As Bristol Turns"...

Anonymous said...

He probably called the Personnel Department (584-6175) and asked to see Rosenthal's file, and they probably told him don't bother because it's empty. It's a public document so they would have to show it to him.

Personnel records do not fall within the realm of public documents. They are protected.

Anonymous said...

I would be surprised if personnel files were open to the public without some authority.

Anyone clarify?

Anonymous said...

Can you imagine the CEO of a corporation spending half his day listening to complaints from customers? Of course not. If the customer is unhappy he can always go somewhere else. So why should a Mayor? Answer: because government IS NOT a business. Government is stuck with its customers, and vice versa. One of the benefits of a Chief Operating Officer is he/she would not have to pander to citizens. He/she would just have to supervise the department heads which is something none of Bristol's mayors have ever been good at, because we've never had a mayor who was a professional manager.

Anonymous said...

Mr. Yarde makes a strong case for a COO..in fact the state of affairs here in Bristol speak to the issue even loader. This city is a union haven because the message is do what we want (pension GASB 45 issue) and we will elect you. Mr. Yarde's appeal is to those of us (majority of Bristol residents) who are not union hacks who want to make Bristol a better place to live and raise our families. The continuity of a COO raise above the union grasp of politicians. How can anyone allow a union member like MCcaulley to be an elected official? What is wrong with people who can see how wrong he is to serve on our council. He is a nice guy, but he is UNION...not a defender of the taxpayers.

Anonymous said...

I heard it was Lori DeFillippi

Steve Collins said...

Personnel records are public documents, though some information within them is not (such as Social Security numbers).

Anonymous said...

LETS FACE IT YOU PEOPLE ARE AFRAID OF YARDE. HE WILL SET THE UNION STRAIGHT AND NOT TAKE PRIOSERS. IT IS ABOUT TIME SOMEONE WILL STAND UP FOR THE TAX PAYERS. THANK GOD.

Anonymous said...

Don't confuse COO and mayor combination (what yard is advocating )with a Town Manger.

A BIG difference.

Anonymous said...

Prediction:
Ellen becomes COO, Ward decides not to run again.

Case closed.

Anonymous said...

Hey Craig, if you are really serious, why don't YOU run for office?
You could run for representative or for Senator, and then next year run for city office and put your ideas to work.
After all, you make it sound so easy, it shouldn't take up much of your time.

Anonymous said...

Be careful what you pray for: your prayers might get answered.

We have a sad record of not thinking things through, and then paying later.

Anonymous said...

I am sure the Ellen as COO comment is a joke but before everyone starts foaming at the mouth, let's not forget that there were five oh-so-powerful dept. heads who were oh-so-scared of Ellen becoming Mayor that they were going to hire a lawyer and ridicule her to make sure their drinking buddy got elected instead. Why? The Craig Yarde accountability factor was at play. She would have been in charge, not them, and maybe they would have had to do their work. God forbid.

Anonymous said...

April 17, 2008 8:49 PM:

Give me a break. That's what we needed a spoiled, self-centered brat who never had a real job coming in and bossing everyone around until they go on strike. Textbook management crisis.

Anonymous said...

Yeah Craig why don't you run for Office? Then you can bare your past that I'm sure even your republican friends don't know about ! See if you can take a dose of the Rat's on here's own medication!

Anonymous said...

....7:13 - That is one nightmarish prediction....what were you using, a ouija board?

Anonymous said...

I'm thinking Zoppo has had a few more real jobs than the current mayor has. But who is splitting hairs, true, she never owned a bar or a breakfast place, or had friends get her state jobs. Yeah, pretty spoiled, having to go out and do all that herself.

Anonymous said...

Craig Yarde has doen his homework. This is not about playing politics, picking sides, it is about doing what is best for the City of Bristol.

Anonymous said...

8:54....I'm thinking that the majority of the voters obviously didn't agree with your point of view....time to get over it.

Anonymous said...

What does Ellen Zoppo have to do with Craig Yardes off the wall idea of a COO?

Lets stick to that topic, unless you are a Yarde fan and are trying to direct attention from his unrealistic idea.

Ellen ran, got elected, did what she thought was right and was an asset to the city.

If the idea of a COO is so good, lets have some justification put forth.

His comments on the way Bristol has been and is run don't seem to be based on any connected experience with the city, except his efforts to get land in Bristol.

Has he served on any board, has he volunteered to serve?
By his own admission he rejected an offer to serve.

Just what is he baseing his suggestion on?

Anonymous said...

April 18, 2008 8:54 AM

I'm thinking, "you're wrong".

Anonymous said...

Mr. Yarde is correct with pushing for the COO. This "off the wall" idea has been embraced by many communities across the country and has been successful. Some of the biggest benefits are continuity, efficiency and accountability. What is wrong with that? I feel the position would pay for itself.

Oh, I would think that Mr. Yarde building a company from the ground up to the point where it could be sold for millions, and the fact that the vast majority of his employees loved working for him, and the fact that his management style was embraced by the new owners and was studied and emulated by other companies, would show that he might have a little bit of experience or knowledge or wisdom on another alternative to the way we manage our city employees.

Then again, he has come out in favor of two Republican initiatives recently, so I guess his feelings are not really for "Moving Bristol For - WARD", they are more like "Putting Bristol First" - that is the taxpayers. SO I guess that is why his ideas or the ones he has expressed support of are "off the wall" and that those who criticize them are not "naysayers", they are just critically minded concerned citizens. Whatever!

Anonymous said...

April 18, 2008 8:54 AM:

Your analysis is false. Do what Ellen is saying and give it up though.

Anonymous said...

April 18, 2008 4:05 PM: said "If the idea of a COO is so good, lets have some justification put forth"


-If you read the release from Yarde, you wouldn't ask this question. I asked the same question but it was answered in this release by Yarde. As a matter of fact this entire release is in regards to why we need a COO.

Anonymous said...

Hmmm Maybe Yarde wants the job? That way he can still run Bristol.

Anonymous said...

Hey 9:05 Don't forget that his business that he buikt from the ground up is now in Southington. Come to think of it don't they have a town manager? Think it might have something to do with Yarde moving his business there?

Anonymous said...

There is a solution to all problems: ufortunately, in many cases it is easy, simple and wrong.

I belive that that is the case with yards proposed solution.

Anonymous said...

Listen to yourselves (hypocrites) You are talking about personel files to be released and you don't even have the guts to say who you are! Ha !!!

Anonymous said...

April 20, 2008 10:50 AM:

We don't work for the city on the tab of the tax-payers. HA to you too!

Anonymous said...

To 11:55 Maybe not but you want to though !! Ha! Rule Bristol!!! HaHaHa

Anonymous said...

April 20, 2008 4:32 PM:

I think people just want efficient, fair city government.

Anonymous said...

10:20 pm And I supposed you are the one to give it too them. LMAO

Anonymous said...

April 21, 2008 3:46 PM:

Actually I'm hoping my aquaintance Mayor Art Ward will.

Anonymous said...

Don't hold your breath!

Anonymous said...

I don't think that what you are seeing is an anti-Yarde sentiment, but a reaction to an idea which has problems, suggested by someone who really hasn't been involved so as to understand the issues, and now, compounded by the fact that his support for a COO is not supported by Town Manager organizations, which indicates he lacks some understanding of the positions.
Craig is a nice guy: I don't think it is personal, but just a legitinmate response.
Bottom line, his credentials while pertinent in other areas, are somewhat weak at best, in this area.